12-19COUNTY OF ELGIN
By-Law No. 12-19
"BEING A BY-LAW TO ADOPT A CODE OF CONDUCT POLICY
FOR COUNCIL TO PROMOTE ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
IN MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE"
WHEREAS Section 8of the Municipal Act, 2001.G.{).2OO1,c.25. provides a
Municipality has the capacity, rights, powers and privileges of a natural person for the
purpose of exercising its authority under this or any other Act; and
WHEREAS PartV.1, Accountability and Transparency, Section 223.2(1) ofthe
Municipal Act, 2001, c. 25, as amended authorizes a Municipality to establish codes of
conduct for members of council of the Municipality and of local boards of the Municipality;
and
WHEREAS the Council of the Corporation of the County of Elgin deems it expedient
to adopt a Code of Conduct Policy that reflects the required ethical and legal requirements
for all members of Council of the Municipality and of local boards of the Municipality for all
deliveries of services;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Municipal Council of the
Corporation of the County of Elgin enacts a Code of Conduct for Council, attached as
Schedule "A" as follows:
1. THAT in the event that section or sections of this by-Iaw thereof are found by
a Court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or ultra virus, such section, sections
or parts thereof shall be deemed to be severable, with all other sections or parts of
this by-law remaining in the full force and effect.
2. THAT this by-law shall take effect upon its adoption.
READ A FIRST, SECOND AND THIRD TIME AND FINALLY PASSED THIS 24TH DAY OF
JULY 2012.
Chief Administrative Officer.
Bill Walters,
SCHEDULE "A" By-Law No.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 1 of 16
12-19
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
Code of Conduct for Members of Municipal Council and, where applicable, Council's
Local Board and Committee Members (herein after referred to as "Members")
Preamble:
Members have important obligations and responsibilities to those they represent, service
and interact with in connection with carrying out the roles and duties attending a Member's
office. A Member's conduct and behavior in terms of ethics and interpersonal conduct
and communications are regulated by legislative acts including the Municipal Act, the
Public Inquiry Act, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Ontario Human Rights
Code, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, and the Municipal Conflict of
Interest Act.
The purpose and intent of this Code of Conduct is a follows:
(i) To establish guidelines for ethical conduct required of Members;
(ii) To establish guidelines to encourage and ensure interpersonal conduct
communications and interactions consistent with legal requirements (i.e.
Occupational Health and Safety Act, Ontario Human Rights Code);
(iii) To provide mechanisms to ensure accountability and compliance with the
required ethical and interpersonal conduct standards of this Code of Conduct.
A. GENERAL STANDARDS OF CONDUCT
1. Members shall conduct themselves at all times in a manner that:
(i) Is consistent with and advances the interests of the community they serve;
(ii) Is consistent with the well-being and interests of the Municipality;
(iii) Is consistent with the Municipality's interest in transparency and accountability;
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 1 of 16
UIb
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as °°Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
Code of Conduct for Members of Municipal Council and, where applicable, Council's
Local Board and Committee Members (herein after referred to as "Members")
Preamble:
Members have important obligations and responsibilities to those they represent, service
and interact with in connection with carrying out the roles and duties attending a Member's
office. A Member's conduct and behavior in terms of ethics and interpersonal conduct
and communications are regulated by legislative acts including the Municipal Act, the
Public Inquiry Act, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Ontario Human Rights
Code, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, and the Municipal Conflict of
Interest Act.
The purpose and intent of this Code of Conduct is a follows:
(i) To establish guidelines for ethical conduct required of Members;
(ii) To establish guidelines to encourage and ensure interpersonal conduct
communications and interactions consistent with legal requirements (i.e.
Occupational Health and Safety Act, Ontario Human Rights Code);
(iii) To provide mechanisms to ensure accountability and compliance with the
required ethical and interpersonal conduct standards of this Code of Conduct.
A. GENERAL STANDARDS OF CONDUCT
1. Members shall conduct themselves at all times in a manner that:
(i) Is consistent with and advances the interests of the community they serve;
(ii) Is consistent with the well-being and interests of the Municipality;
(iii) Is consistent with the Municipality's interest in transparency and accountability;
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 2 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
B.
1.
(iv) Reflects a diligent and impartial exercise of the office held to the best of the
Member's knowledge and ability;
(v)
Reflect the Member's adherence to obligations in connection with avoidance of
conflicts of interest;
(vi) Is consistent with the legal deliverables governing interpersonal interactions (i.e.
civil and respectful, free from harassment or discrimination, free from violence or
the threat of violence).
ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR: CONDUCT REQUIREMENTS
Foster Respect for Decision-making Process
All Members shall accurately and adequately communicate the attitudes and decisions of
the Council, even if they disagree with Council's decision, such that respect for the
decision-making processes of Council is fostered.
2. Strict Adherence to Obligations Regarding Avoiding Conflict of Interest
Members have strict obligations to avoid conflicts of interest by taking the following steps
whenever a member has a direct or indirect pecuniary interest in any matter that is before
Council in a meeting where the member is present:
(i) disclose the general nature of the member's interest prior to any consideration of the
matter in the meeting;
(ii) refrain from participating in the discussion of the matter or in any vote on the matter;
(iii) refrain from attempting to influence the voting on the matter or question, before, during
or after the meeting.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 3 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
All members have important ethical and statutory obligations to adhere to the steps outlined
above to ensure avoidance of any conflict of interest in connection with carrying out the
obligations of the Member's office.
While the Integrity Commissioner may provide general interpretation of the Municipal
Conflict of Interest Act (MCIA), it is expected that members seek independent legal advice
on a specific question of individual compliance with the Act.
3. Release of Confidential Information Prohibited
Members have a duty to hold in strict confidence all information concerning matters dealt
with at In-Camera meetings. Members shall not, either directly or indirectly, release, make
public or in any way divulge any such information or any aspect of the In-Camera
deliberations to anyone, unless expressly authorized by Council or required by law to do
so.
Members shall not release information in contravention of the provisions of the Municipal
Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
Members shall not release information subject to solicitor-client privilege, unless expressly
authorized by Council or required by law to do so.
Members shall not misuse confidential information (information that they have knowledge of
by virtue of their position as Councillor, Board or Committee Member is not in the public
domain, including e-mails and correspondence from other Members of Council, Board or
Committee Member or third parties) such that it may cause detriment to the Corporation,
Council or others, or benefit or detriment to themselves or others.
4. Release of Information to Public and Media
Members acknowledge that official information related to decisions and resolutions made
by Council will normally be communicated to the community and the media by the Council
as a whole or the Warden as Head of Council or by his or her designate.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 4 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
5. Acceptance of Gifts Prohibited
The stipend paid to each Member of Council and Council's Local Board and Committee
Members is intended to fully remunerate Members for service to the Corporation. Members
shall not solicit, accept, offer or agree to accept a commission, reward, gift, advantage or
benefit of any kind, personally or through a family member or friend, which is connected
directly or indirectly with the performance or duties of office.
Members are not precluded from accepting:
(a) personal gifts, normal hospitality among persons doing business, benefits,
rewards, commissions or advantages from any person or organization not
connected directly or indirectly with the performance or duties of office;
(b) political contributions that are otherwise offered, accepted and reported in
accordance with applicable law;
(c) food and beverages at banquets, receptions, ceremonies or similar events;
(d) services provided without compensation by persons volunteering their time;
(e) food, lodging, transportation and entertainment provided by other levels of
governments or by other local governments, boards or commissions;
a reimbursement of reasonable expenses incurred in the performance of duties
or office;
a reimbursement of reasonable expenses incurred and honorariums received in
the performance of activities connected with municipal associations;
token gifts such as souvenirs, mementos and commemorative gifts that are given
in recognition of service on a committee, for speaking at an event or representing
the Corporation at an event; and,
gifts that are received as an incident of protocol or social obligation that normally
and reasonably accompany the responsibility of office.
(1)
Members shall return any gifts or benefits which exceed these limits, along with an
explanation why the gifts or benefits cannot be accepted.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 5 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
6. Engaging in Incompatible Activity Prohibited
Members shall not engage in any activity, financial or otherwise, which is incompatible or
inconsistent with the ethical discharge of official duties in the public interest.
Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, Members shall not:
(a) use any influence of office for any purpose other than official duties;
(b) act as an agent before Council or any committee, board or commission of
council;
(c) solicit, demand or accept the services of any corporate employee, or individual
providing services on a contract for service, for re-election purposes during hours
in which the employee, or individual providing services under a contract for
service, is in the paid employment of the Corporation;
(d) use any information gained in the execution of office that is not available to the
general public for any purpose other than for official duties;
(e) place themselves in a position of obligation to any person or organization which
might reasonably benefit from special consideration or may seek preferential
treatment;
(f) give preferential treatment to any person or organization in which a Member or
Members of Council have a financial interest;
influence any administrative or Council decision or decision-making process
involving or affecting any person or organization in which a Member or Members
of Council have a financial interest; and,
(h) use Corporate materials, equipment, facilities or employees for personal gain or
for any private purpose.
(g)
7. Avoidance of Waste
Members shall avoid waste, abuse and extravagance in the provision of use of public
resources, and shall expose fraud and corruption of which the Member of Council and
Council's Local Board and Committee Member is aware.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 6 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
C. INTERPERSONAL CONDUCT AND COMMUNICATIONS: REQUIREMENTS
General:
Members have important legal responsibilities and accountabilities in connection with the
tone and substance of interpersonal interactions, conduct or communications pursued in
the context of carrying out the activity attending a Member's office.
The purpose of this section of the Code of Conduct and the appendiced policies is to
ensure that Members governed by this Code of Conduct understand and comply with
standards of conduct required at law in terms of their interpersonal interactions,
communications and conduct. (Policies appendiced: Appendix A - Workplace Harassment and
Discrimination Policy; Appendix B - Commitment to a Civil Workplace Environment and Workplace
Interactions Policy; Appendix C - Violence in the Workplace Policy)
The Municipal Corporation and Members, as agents of the Municipal Corporation share
important obligations for ensuring compliance with required standards of interpersonal
conduct and interactions. A failure to adhere to the required Standards of Conduct can
expose both the Municipality, the County, and individual Members to potential liabilities.
I Human Rights Guarantees: The Obligation to Treat Every Person with Dignity,
Understanding and Respect and Avoid Harassment and Discrimination
The Ontario Human Rights Code extends equality rights guarantees in the context of
employment and the delivery of services. A Municipal Government is both an employer
and service provider. As a result the interactions and conduct of Members governed by
this Code of Conduct generally occur in the context of providing services or interacting with
employees.
In connection with such interactions, Members have a legal obligation to ensure adherence
to equality rights guarantees. Members have an obligation to ensure that all individuals
dealt with are treated with dignity and respect, and not exposed to harassment or
discrimination as prohibited by the Human Rights Code.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 7 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8112
As a Member your obligations in this regard extend to anyone you deal with in the context
of employment or delivery of services; including but not necessarily limited to the following:
other Members of Council, Committee Members, Local Board Members, Corporate
Employees, individuals providing services, contractors, students, the public.
(i) Not to Discriminate
In compliance with the Human Rights Code, Members shall not discriminate against
anyone on the basis of their race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship,
creed, sex, sexual orientation, age, record of offences, martial status, same-sex partnership
status, family status, or disability, "age", "disability", "family status", "record of offences",
"same-sex partnership status" shall be as defined in the Human Rights Code.
(ii) Not to Engage in Harassment
In accordance with the Human Rights Code, Members shall not expose anyone to conduct
representing harassment. Harassment includes engaging in a course of vexatious
comment or conduct that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome.
Without limiting the generality of the definition of "harassment", Members shall not:
(a) make racial, homophobic, sexist or ethnic slurs;
(b) display pornographic, homophobic, sexist, racist or other offensive or derogatory
material;
(c) make leering (suggestive staring) or other offensive gestures;
(d) make written or verbal abuse or threats;
(e) vandalize the personal property of others;
(f) commit physical or sexual assault;
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 8 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
(g)
make unwelcome remarks, jokes, innuendoes or taunting statements about a
person's physical appearance, racial background, colour, ethnic origin, place of
origin, citizenship, ancestry, creed (religion or belief), sex, sexual orientation,
age, record of offences, martial status, same-sex partnership status, family
status, disability (physical or mental);
(h) make unwelcome remarks, insulting gestures or jokes which cause
embarrassment or awkwardness;
refuse to converse or interact with anyone because of their racial or ethnic
background, colour, creed, sex, sexual orientation, age, record of offences,
marital status, same-sex partnership status, family status, or disability;
(j) make unnecessary or unwanted physical contact, including touching, patting, or
pinching; and,
(k) demand sexual favours or requests.
(1)
Harassment which occurs in the course of or related to the performance of duties by
Members is subject to this policy and appendiced policies.
II Personal and Psychological Harassment: OHSA
General: Prohibition of Psychological and Personal Harassment
Health and Safety Legislation has identified and prohibited the potential health risk of
"personal harassment" or "psychological harassment' in workplaces. Members must
ensure that their interactions and personal communications and conduct are constructive,
civil and respectful; devoid of any content or tone that would constitute "personal
harassment" or "psychological harassment".
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU /L
Page 9 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members ")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
(i) Avoid Personal or Psychological Harassment
Personal and Psychological Harassment includes unwelcome words and /or actions that are
known or should have been known to be embarrassing, humiliating or demeaning. Such
conduct can include but is not limited to the following:
• remarks, jokes, comments, innuendo that demean, ridicule, intimidate or offend;
• bullying;
• repeated offensive or intimidating phone calls, e- mails, verbal outbursts;
• yelling and screaming, rude demeaning remarks;
• volatile displays of temper or anger;
• exposing people to foul, abusive or obscene language.
Members are required to ensure that they interact and communicate in a manner that is
respectful and consistent with the well being of those they deal with. Members must
ensure that their interactions communications are free of any conduct that would be
considered personal or psychological harassment. (Note: See Policies - Appendix A -
Workplace Harassment and Discrimination Policy; Appendix B - Commitment to a Civil Workplace
Environment and Workplace Interactions Policy; Appendix C - Violence in the Workplace Policy)
III Prohibition of Violence
General: Obligation to Avoid any Conduct Representing Violence or a Threat of
Violence to a Worker
Health and Safety Legislation has introduced serious and significant obligations to ensure
the removal of the risk of violence and threat of violence in Ontario workplaces. Members
must ensure that they avoid any interactions, communications or conduct with employees
that would constitute "Workplace Violence ". Municipal employees have significant rights
and recourse if exposed to any threat of violence or act of violence in connection with work
or work related activity; including conduct by or interactions with Members of Council,
Council's Local Board or Committee Members.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 10 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
(i) Avoid Violence or Conduct Constituting a Threat of Violence
Workplace violence is defined as the exercise of physical force by a person against a
worker in a workplace that causes or could cause physical injury to the worker. To
appreciate the broad nature of the definition of violence, it is important to understand that
violence includes the following:
e an attempt to exercise force that could cause physical injury (Note: does not
have to cause injury);
o a statement or behaviour that could reasonably be interpreted as a threat to
exercise physical force (Note: verbal threats will constitute violence).
Examples:
6 a verbal threat, attack or physical conduct
• threatening notes, e-mails, voice mails communications
e shaking a fist or other threatening physical gestures
• wielding an object as a weapon at an individual
Members are required to ensure that they avoid any interactions, conduct, communications,
or gestures that would constitute a threat of violence or violence. (See Appendix 3,
Violence in the Workplace Policy).
D. COMPLIANCE / ACCOUNTABILITY / ENFORCEMENT
General:
The County has important obligations and interests in ensuring compliance with the ethical
and interpersonal conduct standards required of Members by this Code of Conduct.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 1 1 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members')
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
The County has an interest and obligation to respond to all allegations, complaints or
incidents of alleged conduct inconsistent with the standards outlined in this Code of
Conduct (and appendiced policies) in a manner consistent with the interests and legal
obligations of the County.
The County recognizes that the County and the Members have a mutual interest in
providing and encouraging access to compliance/enforcement mechanisms in connection
with the conduct required by this Code that deliver objective, independent, skilled and
efficient determinations in connection with alleged misconduct by any Member.
The County shall appoint an Integrity Commissioner pursuant to Section 223.3(1) of the
Municipal Act to inquire into and determine any alleged non-compliance with the standards
of conduct defined in the Code of Conduct by a Member.
(Note #1: The referral of alleged breaches of the Code of Conduct to the Integrity
Commissioner under this Code does not preclude the rights of potential
claimants/complainants at law or pursuant to County policies.)
(Note #2: See Appendix 2 for duties of Integrity Commissioner)
In all circumstances where the County becomes aware of an allegation that a Member has
engaged in any prohibited activity or breached any standard of conduct outlined in this
Code of Conduct, whether by informal communications or formal complaints, the matter will
be addressed as follows:
(i) The "informal" complaint procedure attached as Appendix 1 may be followed but
is not mandatory;
(ii) Any issue of non-compliance with the Code of Conduct shall be referred to the
Integrity Commissioner through the Complaint Protocol attached as Appendix 3;
(iii) The Integrity Commissioner shall conduct an Inquiry to determine whether the
Member has engaged in conduct in contravention of the Code of Conduct;
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 12 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
(iv)
In planning and pursuing the relevant inquiry the Integrity Commissioner may
proceed consistent with the procedural aspects of any policies addressing the
subject of the alleged infringement and exercise his/her powers under Section 33
and Section 34 of the Public Inquiries Act;
(v) The inquiry pursued by the Integrity Commissioner shall be an independent
inquiry; independent of the County or any of its agents, employees or members;
(vi) Where the Integrity Commissioner determines that he/she has reasonable
grounds to believe that there has been a contravention of any other act or the
Criminal Code, the Integrity Commissioner shall refer the matter to the
appropriate authority; suspend his/her inquiry and report the suspension to
Council. In these circumstances Council will pursue the necessary steps to
ensure that the matter is addressed consistent with the County's obligations at
law and any relevant County policies;
(vii) Where the Integrity Commissioner completes an inquiry and determination of the
matter, he/she shall prepare a written report of his/her findings as to whether a
Member has contravened the Code of Conduct. Where a contravention of the
Code is substantiated, the Report shall disclose the Penalty determined by the
Integrity Commissioner. In preparing the report, the Integrity Commissioner may
disclose such matters as are necessary for the reporting to Council. The Report
shall be delivered to Council;
(viii) Where the Integrity Commissioner determines that a Member has contravened
the Code of Conduct, the Integrity Commissioner shall determine the penalty;
such penalty shall be within the remedial parameters defined in the Municipal
Act;
(viiii) Penalties: Where a Member is found to have breached any standard of conduct
required by the Code of Conduct, the penalty will be determined by the Integrity
Commissioner. In determining the penalty the Integrity Commissioner shall take
into consideration the nature and degree of the current breach of the Code and
any prior non-compliance with the Code of Conduct by the Member.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 13 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
Penalties imposed in connection with breaches of the Code of Conduct pursuant to the
Code may include:
1. A written reprimand; and or;
2. Suspension of remuneration paid to a Member with respect to services up to 90-
days; and or;
3. Censure including removal from appointed Committees, Boards and/or liaison
roles.
Refusal To Conduct Investigation
(1) If the Integrity Commissioner is of the opinion that the referral of a matter to him or
her is frivolous, vexatious or not made in good faith, or that there are no grounds or
insufficient grounds for an investigation, the Integrity Commissioner shall not
conduct an investigation, or, where that becomes apparent in the course of an
investigation, terminate the investigation.
(2) Complaints referred that are repetitious in nature, not germane to the Code of
Conduct in the opinion of the Integrity Commissioner, deemed frivolous and
without substance in the opinion of the Integrity Officer, OR, where the complaint is
deemed vexatious in the opinion of the Integrity Commissioner, complaints shall
not be advanced to an investigation stage.
(3)
Other than in exceptional circumstances, the Integrity Commissioner will not report
to Council or a local board (restricted definition) on any complaint described in
subsections (1) and (2) except as part of an annual or other periodic report.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 14 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
E. OTHER COMPLAINCE/ENFORCEMENT RIGHTS BEYOND THE REFERRAL TO
THE INTEGRITY COMMISSIONER
While the County encourages complainants, Members and all parties to access and
support the use of the Integrity Commissioner as the means of addressing any issues of
non-compliance with the Code of Conduct by Members, the County has an obligation and
commitment to support complainants or potential complainants access to the following
processes in connection with allegations of prohibited activity, conduct or communications.
1. Complaints of Harassment (Code or Personal), Discrimination, Violence by
Employees, Members of Council
• Access to the procedures committed to in the County's relevant Policies (Le.
informal resolution, mediation, complaint procedures);
• Complainants also have a right to file complaints with the Ontario Human Rights
Tribunal (in connection with human rights allegations) and complaints with the
Ministry of Labour (in connection with allegations of violence, threats of violence
or personal harassment).
2. Complaints Regarding Allegations of Conduct Regulated by the Criminal Code
• Complaints can be directed to the Elgin County Detachment of the Ontario
Provincial Policy to pursue an investigation under Section 122 of the Criminal
Code of Canada where allegations of fraud or breach of trust are made in
connection with a Member carrying out the duties of the office;
• Complaints can be directed to the Elgin County Detachment of the Ontario
Provincial Policy to pursue an investigation under Section 122 of the Criminal
Code of Canada regarding allegations of a Member's involvement in demands for,
acceptance of, offering or agreement to accept a loan, reward, benefit or other
advantage from any person, in connection with the performance of the duties of
the Member in the office;
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 15 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8/12
3. Complainant's Direct Dealings with Members in Connection with Concerns of
Non-Compliance with the Code of Conduct
• Any person who believes that a Member has infringed any standard under this
Code of Conduct can advise the Member of the concern directly (verbally or in
writing) that their activity infringes the Code of Conduct;
• Such person (complainant) may directly encourage the Member to stop the
offending activity;
• Such person (complainant) should keep a record of the incident, including date,
time, location, persons present and any other relevant information.
F. JUDICIAL INVESTIGATION
In circumstances where liability is denied and the alleged misconduct is serious in nature,
Council may pass a resolution, pursuant to s. 274(1) of the Municipal Act, requesting a
judicial investigation into the Member of Council, or Council's Local Board or Committee
Member's conduct.
SUMMARY
The County and all Members of Council share an important interest and responsibility in
ensuring that the standards of conduct required under this Code of Conduct are
understood, maintained and where necessary enforced by holding Members accountable.
The standards reflect the ethical and legal context in which the County and Members must
deliver services to the community served by the Council and Members.
County of Elgin
Human Resources Policy Manual
Code - NU/L
Page 16 of 16
Section: 2
Subject: Code of Conduct for
Members of Municipal Council
And Council's Local Board and
Committee Members (hereinafter
referred to as "Members")
Policy Number: 2.100
Date Approved: Jan. 20, 2004
Date Revised: Nov. 13, 2007
Date Last Revised: May 8112
Deviations from the standards of conduct outlined in this Code of Conduct leave the
County, Council and individual Members exposed to the following:
• Reputational risk;
• Loss of credibility in the community;
6 Risks of significant liabilities.
All Members of Council are expected to be knowledgeable of the contents of this Code of
Conduct and of the appendiced County Policies, and to adhere to the standards of conduct
defined in the Code of Conduct and Policies.
Appendix 1
INFORMAL COMPLAINT PROCEDURE
Individuals (for example, Municipal employees, members of the public, members of Council
or local boards (restricted definition), or organizations (including local boards (restricted
definition) who have identified or witnessed behaviour or an activity by a member of Council
or a local board (restricted definition) that they believe is in contravention of the Code of
Conduct for Members of Council and Local Boards (Restricted Definition) the "Code of
Conduct" would address the prohibited behaviour or activity themselves as follows:
(1) advise the member that the behaviour or activity contravenes the Code of Conduct;
(2) encourage the member to stop the prohibited behaviour or activity;
(3) keep a written record of the incidents including dates, times, locations, other
persons present, and any other relevant information;
(4) tell someone else (for example, a senior staff member or an officer of the
organization) about your concerns, your comments to the member and the
response of the member;
(5)
if applicable, confirm to the member's satisfaction with the response of the
member; or, if applicable, advise the member of your dissatisfaction with the
response; and,
(6) consider the need to pursue the matter in accordance with the formal complaint
procedure outlined in Part B, or in accordance with another applicable judicial or
quasi-judicial process or complaint procedure.
Individuals and organizations are encouraged to initially pursue this informal complaint
procedure as a means of stopping and remedying a behaviour or activity that is prohibited
by the Code of Conduct. With the consent of the complaining individual or organization and
the member, the Integrity Commissioner may be part of any informal process. However, it
is not a precondition or a prerequisite that those complaining pursue the informal complaint
procedure prior to pursing the formal complaint procedure.
Appendix 2
DUTIES OF A MUNICIPAL INTEGRITY COMMISSIONER
The Integrity Commissioner shall perform the duties and have the powers provided for in
the Act, including but not limited to the following:
(1) Advisory: upon proper request, provide written and/or verbal advice to individual members
of Council respecting the application of the Code of Conduct and/or any other procedures, rules,
and policies relating to and reflecting upon their ethical behavior, including but not limited to
general interpretation of the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act (Ontario); and furthermore and
when appropriate, providing the full Council with specific and general opinions and advice
respecting compliance by elected officials in respect of the provisions of governing statues the
Code of Conduct and any other applicable procedures, rules, and policies.
(2) Compliance Investigation/Determinations: upon proper request from a member of Council
or local board, municipal administration or one or more members of the public, to conduct an
inquiry and make a determination as to any alleged contravention of the Code of Conduct or
applicable procedures, rules, and policies by a member of Council or local board and, thereafter,
to report the details and results of such inquiry to municipal Council.
(3) Educational: provide the Chief Administrative Officer or as directed with an annual report
of activities during the previous calendar year as Integrity Commissioner, including but not
necessarily limited to advice given to Council or individual members of Council and a summary
of inquiry results and determinations; furthermore, provide outreach programs to members of
Council and local boards and relevant staff on legislation, protocols, and office procedures
emphasizing the importance of compliance with a Code of Conduct for public confidence in
Municipal Government; and, furthermore, dissemination of information available to the public on
the website operated by Elgin.
Notwithstanding that set forth above, the parties acknowledge and agree that the function of the
Integrity Commissioner is to provide advice and opinion to Council and members thereof, to
provide independent complaint prevention, investigation, adjudication, and resolution to
members of Council and the public, and education respecting adherence with the Code of
Conduct for members of Council and other procedures, rules, and policies governing ethical
behavior.
The parties hereto also acknowledge and agree the Integrity Commissioner, will perform
services, and in particular those services relating to advisory and educational duties, in a
manner so as to avoid duplicated advice, opinion, and cost in respect of identical requests and
inquiries — for example, the Integrity Commissioner shall decline to provide individualized advice
and opinion to more than one member of Council or a local board on identical issues but should
choose to provide general advice to Council or such local board as a whole to answer all such
inquiries. In addition, it is recognized that the Integrity Commissioner, will likely receive requests
for advice on matters involving compliance with the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act (the
"MCIA") — while the Integrity Commissioner may provide general interpretation of the MCIA, it is
expected that individual members of Council or local boards will seek independent legal advice
on a specific question of individual compliance with such legislation.
Appendix 3
COMPLAINT PROTOCOL
(1) Any member of Council, staff or the public that believes they have experienced or
witnessed conduct in contravention with the Code of Conduct may file a
complaint and request an investigation.
(2) All complaints shall be in writing and signed by an identifiable individual.
(3) A complaint shall set out reasonable and probable grounds for the allegation that
the member as contravened the Code of Conduct and include a support affidavit
that sets out the evidence in support of the complaint.
(4) The complaint protocol information package shall be available at the County
Clerk's office.